In 1976, when Hilton Kramer wrote what his New York Times obituary writer called his most provocative article, “The Blacklist and the Cold War,” I still considered myself a man of the political Left. I was therefore rather furious when I read that essay—so furious that I wrote a lengthy reply to Hilton, co-signed with a friend, which, when I read it now, causes me to blanch with embarrassment. Hilton responded by writing that I could not “face the worst about Stalinism,” nor could I acknowledge “a simple fact: without Stalinism there would have been no McCarthyism and no blacklist.”

Less than ten years later, I came to realize just how right Hilton Kramer was. By then, I was writing my own articles reevaluating the “Cold War revisionism” of left-wing scholars I had once found profound but had come to see as very seriously flawed. Therefore, when Peter Collier and David Horowitz...

 

New to The New Criterion?

Subscribe for one year to receive ten print issues, and gain immediate access to our online archive spanning more than four decades of art and cultural criticism.

Popular Right Now